What Happens When Co-Trustees Cannot Agree in California

Two siblings in La Jolla were named co-trustees of their mother’s trust. One wants to sell the family home on Draper Avenue before the market softens. The other refuses to sign, insisting the house stay in the family for another year. Six months later, the property taxes are past due, the beneficiaries have received no distributions, and neither sibling will move without the other’s signature. This is a co-trustee deadlock, and it can create serious problems in California trust administration when the trustees cannot agree on decisions needed to manage or protect trust property.

Under California Probate Code Section 15620, a power held by two or more trustees generally can only be exercised through unanimous action unless the trust instrument provides otherwise. That default rule can allow one co-trustee to block an action when the trust instrument does not provide another method for making decisions. Probate Code Section 15620 expressly applies unless otherwise provided in the trust instrument.

During a prolonged deadlock, necessary actions such as managing investments, paying expenses, maintaining property, or making authorized distributions may be delayed. The effect depends on the trust terms, the nature of the disputed decision, and the trustees’ legal duties. The longer a dispute continues, the greater the risk that delayed decisions could cause financial or administrative problems for the trust and its beneficiaries.

Key Deadlines When Co-Trustees Are Deadlocked

  • Co-trustees cannot reach unanimous agreement and the trust has no contrary decision-making provision. There is no general statutory deadline for resolving a deadlock, but prolonged inaction may increase financial harm and may become evidence that trust administration is being impaired. Probate Code Section 15620 governs the default unanimous-action rule, while Probate Code Section 15642 provides grounds for removal in appropriate cases.
  • Filing a petition for instructions to address a deadlock. There is no general statutory filing deadline for a petition seeking instructions under Probate Code Section 17200. The appropriate timing depends on the circumstances, including whether continued inaction threatens trust property or beneficiary interests.
  • Petition to remove a co-trustee whose hostility or lack of cooperation impairs trust administration. Probate Code Section 15642(b)(3) identifies impaired administration caused by hostility or lack of cooperation among co-trustees as a potential ground for removal. The statute does not establish a fixed filing deadline.
  • Beneficiary claim for breach of trust. Under Probate Code Section 16460, the claim generally must be brought within three years after the beneficiary receives an account or written report that adequately discloses it or, without adequate disclosure, within three years after the beneficiary discovers or reasonably should have discovered it.
  • Objecting to an item in a trustee’s account or report. An objection period of at least 180 days applies only when the trust contains a qualifying provision and the notice requirements of Probate Code Section 16461 are met. It is not a universal deadline.

The Unanimous Action Rule Is the Root of Almost Every Co-Trustee Fight

California establishes a default unanimous-action rule for co-trustees. Unless the trust instrument provides otherwise, a power vested in two or more trustees may be exercised only through unanimous action. If the trust document does not provide a different decision-making process, every trustee generally must agree on actions such as selling real property, approving a distribution, or hiring a property manager. With two trustees, one holdout can prevent an action that requires unanimous approval. The same default rule applies when there are three or more co-trustees. Unless the trust instrument provides another decision-making mechanism, the trustees must act unanimously even when a majority favors a particular action.

When co-trustees cannot resolve a dispute privately and the trust does not provide an effective alternative, a trustee or beneficiary may petition the probate court concerning the trust’s internal affairs. Probate Code Section 17200 expressly permits proceedings to instruct a trustee and address other matters involving trust administration. The unanimous-action rule can protect beneficiaries from unilateral action by one trustee, but it can also create an obstacle when co-trustees cannot agree on how the trust should be administered.

The Trust Document May Change the Default Rule

Probate Code Section 15620 is a default rule. Before assuming that every decision requires unanimous approval, the trustees should review the trust instrument for provisions governing co-trustee decision making, delegation, resignation, succession, dispute resolution, or majority action. The trust may establish a different procedure for exercising trustee powers.

This review should happen before treating a disagreement as a statutory deadlock. A provision in the trust may determine whether one trustee can act independently, whether a majority can act, or whether another decision-making process applies to a particular issue.

What a Co-Trustee Deadlock Actually Looks Like in a High-Value Estate

Deadlock rarely announces itself as a single dramatic event. It builds through a pattern of stalled decisions that, individually, might look like ordinary disagreement, but together demonstrate that the trust can no longer function.

Common deadlock patterns include the following.

  • One co-trustee refuses to sign off on the sale of a San Diego family home, investment property, or closely held business interest, while the other insists a sale is necessary to fund required distributions
  • Co-trustees cannot agree on how to value or divide LLC interests or a jointly owned business, leaving the asset frozen in place
  • One trustee wants an aggressive investment strategy for a portfolio while the other wants to hold cash, and neither will compromise
  • A co-trustee refuses to provide information or cooperate with trust administration, making it difficult for the trustee or trustees to fulfill accounting obligations under Probate Code Section 16062
  • One trustee stops responding to the other entirely, effectively vetoing every decision through silence rather than an actual disagreement

When co-trustees cannot agree in California and the trust instrument is silent on how to resolve it, the dispute does not necessarily resolve itself. It can remain unaddressed while trust property continues to require management, expenses continue to accrue, and important decisions remain unresolved.

The Petition for Instructions Under Probate Code Section 17200

When co-trustees genuinely cannot reach the unanimous agreement the trust requires, either trustee may petition the superior court under Probate Code Section 17200 concerning the internal affairs of the trust, including a request for instructions concerning the administration of the trust. The petition may draw objections or a competing petition from the other trustee, which can turn a request for guidance into a contested trust proceeding.

Under Probate Code Section 17203, the petitioner generally must cause notice of the hearing to be delivered at least 30 days before the hearing to all trustees and beneficiaries, subject to the statutory provisions governing notice.

The timing varies by court and by the complexity of the dispute. A contested petition may require additional briefing, evidence, discovery, or other proceedings before the court resolves the issue. That timeline matters because trust property, particularly real estate carrying a mortgage or a business that depends on active management, does not wait quietly for a court date. A co-trustee facing an unresolved deadlock should consider the appropriate legal process and whether court intervention is necessary to protect the trust and its beneficiaries.

When Deadlock Becomes Grounds for Co-Trustee Removal

Not every disagreement supports removing a co-trustee. California law distinguishes between ordinary friction and conduct that actually impairs trust administration. Probate Code Section 15642 provides several potential grounds for removal, including breach of trust, unfitness, hostility or lack of cooperation among co-trustees that impairs trust administration, failure or refusal to act, and other good cause. A settlor, co-trustee, or beneficiary may petition for removal under Section 17200.

Evidence that may support removal can include a documented history of stalled decisions, missed deadlines on required accountings, refusal to communicate, or financial harm to the trust, such as an unpaid mortgage, a lapsed insurance policy, or a lost opportunity to sell an asset. The key issue is whether the circumstances meet a statutory ground for removal, rather than simply whether the trustees disagree.

If trust property or a beneficiary’s interests may suffer loss or injury while a removal petition is pending, Probate Code Section 15642(e) permits the court to suspend the trustee’s powers to the extent necessary or require trust property to be surrendered to a co-trustee, receiver, or temporary trustee. Full statutory language is available through the California Legislative Information.

A Deadlock Does Not Automatically Mean a Trustee Should Be Removed

Disagreement alone does not automatically justify removing a co-trustee. Probate Code Section 15642 identifies hostility or lack of cooperation as a potential ground for removal when it impairs the administration of the trust. Other statutory grounds include breach of trust, failure or refusal to act, unfitness, and other good cause.

A trustee who disagrees with a proposed sale or investment decision is not necessarily acting improperly. The important question is whether the trustee’s conduct is actually impairing trust administration or otherwise violates a legal duty.

The Financial Exposure of Waiting Out a Deadlock

A co-trustee who stalls can create serious problems for the trust. Each co-trustee remains subject to the fiduciary duties applicable to the trust and the trustee’s role. A refusal to act or cooperate may support a breach-of-trust claim when the conduct violates a duty and causes legally compensable harm, but disagreement alone does not automatically establish a breach. If a stalled decision causes the trust to lose value through missed rental income, a declined property sale, unpaid taxes, or poor investment management, a beneficiary or co-trustee may seek an appropriate remedy under California law. Probate Code Section 16420 provides remedies for a breach or threatened breach of trust, while Section 16440 addresses losses and other amounts that may be charged to a trustee for a breach. The full scope of these duties trustees owe beneficiaries under California law extends beyond simply cooperating with a co-trustee.

Beneficiaries who wait too long can also lose ground on their own claims, because the three-year period under Probate Code Section 16460 can begin running while the trustees remain deadlocked. Beneficiaries who assume the deadlock will resolve itself should keep track of the statute of limitations for trust claims so that an otherwise valid claim does not become time-barred.

San Diego Assets Most Often Caught in Co-Trustee Standoffs

High-value trusts in San Diego, Orange, Los Angeles, Riverside, and San Bernardino Counties tend to hold assets that are especially vulnerable to a co-trustee standoff because they require an active decision to preserve their value.

  • Family homes and vacation properties where one co-trustee wants to sell and the other wants to retain the property for personal or sentimental reasons
  • Closely held businesses or professional practices that need ongoing management decisions the co-trustees cannot agree on
  • LLC interests and commercial real estate holdings that require timely decisions on refinancing, leasing, or sale
  • Investment portfolios where a disagreement over risk tolerance leaves assets mismanaged or entirely unmanaged
  • Rental property portfolios that generate ongoing income and expenses requiring continuous, coordinated decision making

Because some of these assets can lose value when necessary decisions are delayed, a deadlock involving them can escalate quickly and increase the costs of administration.

Resolving a Co-Trustee Conflict Before It Becomes Irreversible

Resolving co-trustee conflicts in California generally follows one of three paths, and the right path depends on how far the dysfunction has already gone.

  1. Formal mediation between co-trustees. When the underlying relationship can still function, mediation may help the trustees reach an agreement about how to manage the disputed issue. If the proposed resolution requires changing the trust’s terms, additional statutory requirements or court approval may apply.
  2. A petition for instructions under Probate Code Section 17200. When the trustees need court direction but cannot agree on the decision itself, this petition can ask the court to address the specific issue without necessarily removing either trustee.
  3. A petition for removal under Probate Code Section 15642. When one trustee’s conduct, rather than simply a disagreement, is impairing trust administration, removal may be available if a statutory ground is established. If a trustee is removed and a sole successor trustee is properly appointed, the unanimous-action issue between co-trustees may no longer apply.

The right strategy depends on the facts and the available documentation. Courts look at the circumstances showing whether trust administration is actually being impaired, rather than simply whether the trustees get along. That makes early legal advice about documenting the dispute an important step for a beneficiary or co-trustee facing an ongoing conflict.

Key Takeaways

  • Probate Code Section 15620 generally requires unanimous action by co-trustees unless the trust provides another decision-making process.
  • The trust document should be reviewed first to determine whether it allows majority action or provides another way to resolve disagreements.
  • A petition under Probate Code Section 17200 may allow a trustee or beneficiary to seek court instructions concerning trust administration.
  • Disagreement alone does not justify removal. Probate Code Section 15642 provides removal grounds when circumstances such as impaired administration, breach of trust, or failure to act meet the statutory requirements.
  • A three-year limitations period under Probate Code Section 16460 may apply when an account or written report adequately discloses a breach-of-trust claim.
  • Documentation of stalled decisions, trust losses, and impaired administration can help establish the circumstances surrounding a co-trustee dispute.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q. What happens if co-trustees cannot agree on selling trust property in California?

A. Under Probate Code Section 15620, the sale generally cannot proceed without both trustees’ agreement unless the trust provides another decision-making process. Either trustee or a beneficiary may petition under Section 17200 for instructions concerning the trust’s administration. Removal may also be available under Section 15642 if a co-trustee’s conduct is actually impairing trust administration.

Q. Can one co-trustee act alone if the other refuses to cooperate?

A. Generally, no, unless the trust instrument or applicable law authorizes independent action. Probate Code Section 15620 generally requires unanimous action when a power is vested in two or more trustees.

Q. How do you remove a co-trustee for causing a deadlock in California?

A. A settlor, beneficiary, or co-trustee may petition under Probate Code Section 15642 when a statutory ground for removal exists. Hostility or lack of cooperation can support removal when it impairs trust administration.

Q. How long does a co-trustee dispute take to resolve in probate court?

A. The timeline varies depending on the court, whether the matter is contested, the evidence involved, and whether additional proceedings are necessary.

Q. What is the deadline to sue a co-trustee for losses caused by a deadlock?

A. Under Probate Code Section 16460, the deadline generally depends on disclosure. If an account or written report adequately discloses the claim, the beneficiary generally has three years from receipt to bring the proceeding. If it does not, the three-year period generally begins when the beneficiary discovers or reasonably should have discovered the claim.

Q. Does mediation work for co-trustee disputes?

A. It can, particularly when the trustees can still work together and the dispute involves a specific decision rather than a pattern of misconduct. If mediation would require changing the trust’s terms, additional requirements may apply.

A Frozen Trust Does Not Fix Itself

Every month a co-trustee deadlock continues, the trust can lose ground that a court cannot always restore. A property sale that made sense at today’s valuation may not make sense after another six months of holding costs. A business decision that needed to happen this quarter cannot be undone once the opportunity passes. Unless the trust instrument provides otherwise, the unanimous-action rule under Probate Code Section 15620 does not pause while trustees work things out privately. If a trustee’s conduct breaches a fiduciary duty or otherwise meets the requirements for a legal remedy, continued delay may also increase the potential consequences for the trust and the trustee involved.

The Casiano Law Firm represents beneficiaries and co-trustees in trust administration disputes, trustee removal proceedings, and trust litigation throughout Southern California, including disputes involving family homes, closely held businesses, and investment portfolios where important decisions remain unresolved.

Contact the firm to discuss a co-trustee dispute before continued delays create additional problems.

Share

Get Customized Personal Solutions!

Long Format Form

Dealing with trust and estate disputes? Fill out this form to get the help you need!

Need a Comprehensive Estate and Strategic Elder Law Planning?

With years of experience in Elder Law and Estate Planning, San Diego Estate Planning Attorney Vinny Casiano helps his clients understand the pros and cons of each strategy to make the best decision for themselves and their families. Finally, he assists his clients in carrying out whatever strategy they have decided is best for them.

Got Probate or Trust Concerns? Get Help NOW!

Whether your concern is about will or trust contests, fiduciaries, or complicated estate plans, San Diego probate and trust litigation attorney Vincent Casiano is here to help. Get high-quality and personalized legal solutions that will address your needs today!

Wide Format Form

Dealing with trust and estate disputes? Fill out this form to get the help you need!